At the RT conference, I went to one presentation where a charming southern-belle-of-a-writer ended her presentation with pulling out an empty suitcase and laying it open on the floor. Then she grabbed a large manila envelope—full to busting—and removed a single sheet of paper.
The writer asked, “When should a writer give up? When they receive one rejection letter?”
She dropped a single rejected letter from that envelope into the suitcase and asked, “Two?”
Two more went into the suitcase.
“Ten? Twelve?”
An even dozen floated down like feathers.
“How about fifty? A hundred? Two hundred?”
By the time she was finished, over 500 rejection letters littered the floor.
She is now a multi-published novelist with deals for at least three more books and rumors of a Lifetime TV series based off of one of her series.
Think we can learn something from this woman?
Oh, yeah.
Handling Rejection Panel
- Rejection comes all throughout a writer’s career, even once you’re published, even if you’re in the middle of a series.
- Rejection can be a friend—you have to wade through the No’s to get to the Yes’s.
- Don’t give time or energy to rejections. File it away and keep looking for new markets.
- If you see a trend in your rejection letters, look at what they’re saying and review your work. Ex: if editors keep telling you your main character is unlikable, then look back through your manuscript for places where he/she might be floundering in the characterization-pool.
- Editors come and go between publishing houses, and have very LONG memories. If they rejected you once, don’t send the same manuscript to them.
- There are three different types of rejections:
- Doesn’t fit their market; not what that editor/agent likes to read. Might not be the right time (ex: vampire fiction popularity ebbs and flows)
- Suggested changes to your characters (not sassy enough, someone should have amnesia, etc). May be an invitation to resubmit, either that story or a different one (because they might not have been able to sell the one you sent them, but liked your voice enough to want to see something else from you).
- “Just not working.” After a repeated stream of these, it might be time to either shelve the book for now, or have a professional editor look at it.
- You must always be willing to make suggested changes to your work.
- Being professional counts in your favor. Keep in mind that both writing and publishing are businesses.
- As soon as you finish a project and start sending it out, begin working on a new story. Remember—you’re only as good as your last sell-through.
- Form rejection letters might mean your first page isn’t hooking enough.
- Mention in query letters that this is a resubmission if resending to someone you queried before who suggested revisions. (If they send you a business card back in your SASE, staple it to the query letter when resubmitting.)
- Send Thank You’s to the editors who take the time to send you a personalized rejection letter. Add this function to your submission tracking tool.
- Mention, “It was a pleasure to meet you at _____.” Then, include their business card to prove that you did actually meet them. (Obviously doesn’t work well for e-queries, so remind that agent/editor of where you were when you spoke to them, and perhaps mention a non-pitching aspect of the conversation—if you bonded over a favorite book or movie, for example.)
- Mention if you’ve won a contest (ONLY if you won) in the query.
- Some editors from larger houses will search small presses and epublishers for emerging authors with great voices.
- Always keep copies of your original versions. You never know when someone wants to see it.
- If you’ve completely rewritten your manuscript since your first round of submissions and want to resubmit to the same agent/publishing house, change the title of the novel and resubmit.
Here are some links to websites listing alternate ways to view and use your rejection letters:
A nice “this is what you do now” list for garnering gems from rejection letters.
http://www.right-writing.com/published-rejection.html
The rejection process from an editor’s point of view.
http://www.myamericanartist.com/2008/07/putting-a-posit.html
The rejection process from the point of view of artists.
http://www.prweb.com/releases/2005/09/prweb290039.htm
This one just makes me laugh!
Hope this helps ease the sting of rejection a bit.
Happy Writing!
Lori

